by Toby Forward
I was pretty excited when Dragonborn finally came in. It looked perfect for elementary - cool cover, not too thick, but not too thin, etc. Turns out, looks can be decieving. I think. I'm not certain yet. Lemme 'splain.
First, a summary: Sam is a wizard apprentice to the great wizard Flaxfield. At the beginning of the book, Flaxfield dies and Sam must oversee his "finishing". All the wizards who completed their apprenticeship under Flaxfield begin to return, and they doubt Sam's abilities and they even begin to doubt whether or not he really was an apprentice. Sam, who has really only ever known life with Flaxfield, fears that these adult wizards plan to send him off to the coal mines to work and decides to run away with his pet dragon Starback. His adventures lead him to a wizard college and to the mines that he is so afraid of. All the while, an evil...person? being? someone of indeterminate species... named Ash is after Sam...I think. It seems that Flaxfield trapped her, and her creepy unexplained companion named Bakkmann in a tower somewhere and if they can get Sam, they can get out. There are also roffles (they seem like dwarfs, but I'm not certain) and memmonts (no idea really - maybe they're cats?) and all kinds of other magical things that inhabit Sam's world that are explained only through excerpts from Sam's apprentice notebook. Oh yeah, and dragons. I almost forgot the dragons.
Was that summary odd? Well, it makes sense because the book is rather odd. The excerpts from Sam's apprentice notebook are meant to connect things together and to give background information, but often end up confusing the reader. I went back and re-read the excerpts often, trying to make sense of the story line through the excerpts. But usually, that didn't help. The chapters and sections that relate to Ash and Bakkmann are just as confusing, but end up making sense at the end of the novel, even if they don't answer all the questions they raise at the beginning. The book is clearly written to be part of a series, I'm just not certain its written well enough to encourage readers to read the rest of the series.
However, I'm an adult, and I read books very differently than my students. There have been books in the past that are similar to Dragonborn that I didn't enjoy and my students LOVE. Since the book is written for young readers, I think I should reserve my judgement about the book until I can get an expert opinion or two about it. So I'm going to book talk it this week, hope someone checks it out and then ask their opinion. I promise I'll report back if I can.
In the meantime, I would recommend this book to any young reader interested in fantasy, mystery and dragons. The reading level places it at a 4th grade level (at least), and I think students up to 7th grade would enjoy it.
*I couldn't help myself. That video is so unbelievably random and weird, it's awesome. Also, I bet that guy is single.